Booked, Blonde & Busy

Olivia Ponton says 'The Deal' is too unrealistic to take seriously, and that's the point

Feb 16, 2026 · 16:27

Summary

Ponton admits the fake-dating hockey romance is 'a little too unrealistic and just a little dramatic and honestly a little weird at times', but argues that's exactly what makes it work.

Ponton opens her Valentine's Day episode by admitting something most BookTok girlies won't say out loud: The Deal by Elle Kennedy is cringe. Not in a dismissive way, but in the way you'd describe a rom-com you watched three times in one weekend. She calls it "a little too unrealistic and just a little dramatic and honestly a little weird at times," then immediately pivots to why that doesn't matter. The book is pink, it's fluffy, it's fake-dating meets hockey romance, and it does exactly what it sets out to do.

That claim, that The Deal succeeds because it leans into its own ridiculousness, is the through-line of the episode. Ponton isn't here to defend the book as great literature. She's here to explain why it works as a gateway drug.

Hannah Wells is guarded, Garrett Graham is a golden retriever, and the pacing is driven by trauma

Ponton spends most of the episode unpacking the two leads. Hannah is the smart, gorgeous, nerdy girl who wants to date Justin, a hockey player who barely notices her. Garrett is the cocky jock who needs tutoring to keep his scholarship. They strike a deal: she tutors him, he makes her visible at parties so Justin will finally pay attention. Classic fake-dating setup.

But Ponton zeroes in on what makes the dynamic work (and occasionally not work). Hannah's guardedness isn't just a personality quirk. She was drugged at a party before the book starts, and that trauma shapes how slowly she lets Garrett in. Ponton notes that Hannah's anxiety around intimacy keeps the book from tipping into the "sexiness" of an Ana Huang or Colleen Hoover novel. The pacing is dictated by consent, by trust, by the fact that Hannah doesn't drink until she's sure Garrett will take care of her.

"For her to have this big moment of her going to the bar and getting super drunk off of piña coladas and trusting that Garrett is going to take care of her and take her home, that's like full trust you can have in a human being." Olivia Ponton

Garrett, meanwhile, gets the golden retriever boyfriend treatment. Ponton admits he starts out as a "cocky, ruthless, know-it-all boy," but he gets humbled fast, first by Hannah's sass, then by his failing grades, and eventually by his own family trauma. His father is an abusive ex-hockey star who beats his girlfriend and holds Garrett's tuition over his head. Ponton argues that once you understand why Garrett is the way he is, the rest of his actions click into place. He's desperate to be good enough, and Hannah becomes the first person who doesn't need him to be.

The breakup is the book's biggest misstep, and Ponton has notes

Ponton's least favorite part of the book is the third-act breakup. Garrett's dad threatens to cut off his tuition unless he stops seeing Hannah, and Hannah, taking the threat seriously, ends things without telling Garrett why. Ponton calls it "honestly a little shocking," and you can hear the frustration in her voice. She doesn't buy that Hannah would let a narcissistic control freak dictate her love life, and she thinks the book goes "so extreme" with the silent treatment that it undercuts the relationship they'd been building.

"If I could change one thing about the book, it would be that I don't think they needed to go so extreme of not speaking to each other." Olivia Ponton

She also has a bone to pick with the Justin subplot. Hannah spends the first half of the book obsessed with this guy, finally gets him to notice her, then ghosts him the second she realizes she has feelings for Garrett. Ponton's reaction: "I feel like he deserves a little bit more than that. Like I feel like we need a story line on that. And maybe I am just uneducated and maybe there's a full book on Justin. I hope so." (There is not.)

The real argument: this book is a product, and it knows it

Ponton returns again and again to the idea that The Deal is a gateway book. It's light enough that you won't get scared off, but it has just enough emotional depth, just enough trauma, just enough tension, that it doesn't feel like total fluff. She compares it to the kind of book that thrives on BookTok because it's designed to be devoured in one sitting. It's 388 pages, it's dialogue-heavy, and the world-building is minimal because Kennedy trusts you to fill in the blanks. You know what a college classroom looks like. You know what a hockey party feels like. The book doesn't waste time on description.

Ponton also notes that Amazon is adapting the series, and she's already strategizing how long to wait between reading the sequels and watching the show. (She learned that lesson the hard way after watching a book adaptation too soon and getting let down by her own expectations.) Her one demand for the adaptation: they better keep the nickname "Welsie," or she's out.

The verdict: cringe is not a dealbreaker

Ponton never quite says whether she liked the book. What she says is that it does what it's supposed to do. It's cheesy, it's unrealistic, it's a little weird, and that's fine. Not every book needs to be a literary event. Some books just need to be pink and fluffy and easy to binge on Valentine's Day.

She ends the episode by joking that she needs someone to actually discuss these books with, because talking to herself about fake-dating tropes is starting to feel a little unhinged. Fair.

Featured guests

Topics & books

Full Transcript

Hi angels

Welcome back to another episode of Booked and Busy

Happy Valentine's Day

And in honor of Valentine's Day, we are going to be talking about a very loveydovey romance book called The Deal by L

Kennedy

This was a book that honestly was requested numerous amounts of times to chat about on Booked Busy

And I thought it would be perfect because it's pink and it's Valentine's Day and it's love and honestly it's like a little cringe

So I feel like that all wraps into Valentine's Day as a holiday. due to feedback from all of you guys, you want less of a synopsis about the book and rather my deep intellectual thoughts about it

So, that's what we're going to do a little bit of today

So, incredibly, incredibly quick synopsis

We have Hannah and Garrett

I hope you can see that on the camera

Basically, this is like a fake dating trope book

And honestly, when I first heard about it, I was like, I just don't know if I'm going to like that because I normally don't read books that are happening in like a regular college experience

I more so read like dark academia books, which is like college, but not really

So, Hannah Wells, the very classic, smart girl who's gorgeous, and she decides to tutor Garrett because he is flunking out of school

And if he flunks out of school, he loses his hockey scholarship

Do you get what I'm going at? And in exchange for Hannah tutoring Garrett, Garrett starts to hang around her a little bit more often to get other guys to notice her because Hannah's kind of like a nerdy girl and Hannah really wants this guy named Justin

So in a logical boy brain, Garrett's like, "Oh, if I hang out with you, that means Justin's going to want you." I don't really know how that makes sense, but it does

So transparently, there is a mutual benefit in the beginning

I think to start right off in the beginning of the book when Hannah is working at the diner and some I don't know if I can say this but some walks in and it ends up being Garrett that kind of like sets you up for a bit of enemies to lovers and I'm not entirely sure if you could say this trope is an enemies to lovers book. [laughter] I just like reading and I just see like little increments of Hannah just being like a really sassy girl and Garrett just like kind of eats it up

I think from the author's perspective, having this quote like deal sets you up for a perfect romantic setting because you have this very classic trope of her being like this smart, you know, cute, shy girl and then he's like the jock who everyone loves and everyone wants but everyone wants him besides her

And personally, while I was reading this book, I feel like I almost had a sense of like cringe and I just was kind of like, okay, there was certain parts of it where I was like, this is just like a little too unrealistic and just a little dramatic and honestly a little weird at times

But I think for an overall series to have that aspect of it is very intriguing, especially for book talk

I mean, this was recommended to me from book talk by numerous numerous people

So, I think this book is the perfect one for someone that is just getting into reading because I feel like it's still very light-hearted

There is some trigger warnings

There are some trauma

So, I think it's the perfect amount of like lightness, but it also gets into the characters and their depth and why they do the things that they do

I think also her anxiety around intimacy makes this book a very light-hearted read rather than someone like Anna Hong or Colleen Hoover or some of those other books that just have like a lot of sexiness to it, which is like great for Valentine's Day, but maybe not for this book

I think where they have it is like that's enough, you know? We we'll cut it off there

I think Hannah is honestly a very guarded human being after the trauma that she went through

I'm going to put a trigger warning right here

We're talking about roofing

So, if that is something that you cannot watch, please skip forward a little bit

But, I think when Hannah is opening up to the readers before she opens up to Garrett, we get to see like a sneak peek and behind the curtain look of, you know, why she acts the way that she is and why she is so guarded with her feelings and how she doesn't date anyone or talk to anyone

I think the root of it is from what she has gone through in the past and how she's scared to trust anyone to be quite transparent

And then I think on the flip end, Garrett has a lot of insecurities

I think they're based and rooted from the father because the father is just uh terrible

Absolutely terrible

And then going off of that, Hannah's acceptance of Garrett in her life takes a really long time because of what has happened to her and her level of consent that she's willing to kind of give to a guy

Obviously, at the beginning of the book, she wants Justin

He's like this like golden retriever boy that she just thinks is like super hot and he he plays hockey and she ends up actually scoring a date with him and he pays attention to her after Garrett is giving her constant affection and attention at parties and class and whatnot

And then we all know that Henna eventually uh turns him down in kind of a weird way, cancels on him, skips out on it, whatever you whatever you want to call it

And she does that because I think think she starts developing feelings for Garrett

And she no longer wants to approach someone who she had she had to kind of play a game with in their head and her head to even get him to pay attention to her

Whereas with Garrett, I feel like honestly it's kind of the same thing cuz they were fake dating

But I digress

And I think Hannah's relationship with consent honestly affects the pacing of the book because at the beginning, you know, it's a fake dating situation where they don't actually like each other

They kind of hate each other

I think she kind of hates him

I don't think he hates her that much

And then as readers, we find out why she acts the way that she does or why she says certain things

And then once she tells Garrett, I feel like that's the moment where all vulnerabilities are just on the line and she's, you know, trusting him with this like deep deep deep secret and showcasing to him that she is now fully trusting him

And I think we know that because the panic colada scene in the bar and she just gets like oblivated with him

And then for her after she was ruied, she didn't really drink

So, for her to have this big moment of her going to the bar and getting super drunk off of pin coladas and trusting that Garrett is going to take care of her and take her home, that's like full trust you can have in a human being

Like, if you're someone that goes out and parties and the first time you have like a man there or someone that is in your life that is kind of like a protector of you, going out with them for the first time ever is kind of like a ooh, this is nice

And going off of that, I feel like Hannah is asking for a lot throughout this entire book, but I never feel like it gets to the point where it's too much

And I think that is because of Garrett transparently and for him being so open and honestly, he gets to a point where he is her little golden retriever and he just wants to make her the happiest girl in the world

So having him be there for her and just like the little moments like you know when they fall asleep watching the TV together or you know the little slow moments where they're tutoring and they just like there's like that crazy amount of tension

I feel like Garrett always makes her feel incredibly safe

I also think this specific book has a level of almost realness to it because as someone who is reading it, I feel like I can relate to Hannah in a lot of ways

Maybe not the college aspect, but the things that she's going through and the level that you have to kind of like open up yourself to once something very traumatic happens to you

Like having that first person come back into your life after said thing happens to you is very scary

And I feel like L

Kennedy wrote it pretty well

Again, everyone kind of goes through different situations, especially when they're coming back from something like that

But I think that's why I felt like Hannah was so real in my brain because I felt like I would be friends with someone like that

And I feel like I could see myself being in a situation where she's my friend and I'm giving her advice and I feel like I was almost there

And then we have Garrett Graham to be specific

I think when we first meet him in the book, he's this like cocky, ruthless, know-it-all boy who just thinks he's the hottest person in the entire world. and he gets humbled very quickly by Hannah and I think also by the fact that um his grades are flunking levels

But I think as the book goes on, we see him for why he's acting that way and for his true colors

And I saw a lot about this on social media kind of like conspiracy theoryesque of why he acts the way that he does

I think it's very much rooted from trigger warning

I'd like to put up another one for physical abuse specifically within families

But in this book, Garrett has a very negative relationship with his father

He was this great hockey player and he expects for Garrett to live up to his kind of like found fame that he has from this

And anything that Garrett does is just never good enough

And obviously when you're reading the book, they go to I think it was Thanksgiving at Garrett's dad's house

And that was like a huge moment for Garrett kind of letting Hannah into like his trauma that he has

And when Garrett sees the wounds on Garrett's dad's new girlfriend, Garrett just kind of like freaks out the dad and is like, "I thought you were done with this

I thought you were over." Like the dad was just really preaching about how he was getting better

And then we find out that Garrett's dad was lying and Garrett made a huge fuss, left

Obviously Hannah went with him

But once we get to that point in the book, a lot of the other actions that Garrett does makes a lot of sense and you kind of see a soft point of him and a vulnerable part of him

And I will say I think Garrett is like the perfect boyfriend for Hannah

And I know there's also discourse about Logan being in the picture because we obviously know that Logan was flirting with her a little bit throughout the book and Garrett was pretty fast to shut that down

But I think as a reader, it's really cute to see a guy that is just so obsessed and in love with his girlfriend and how nerdy she is and how smart she is and he really starts taking pride in the fact that like she's his tutor and that he's learning more and getting better

I think one of the turning points in the book when Garrett starts getting a little bit more serious about her is when Garrett kisses Hannah at a party and then Hannah goes and kisses another dude 2 seconds after

I think that hit a nerve in Garrett and he was like, "Oh, maybe I do like her a little bit." But I honestly think it was kind of a slowburn on both their ends

They both started realizing that they were really enjoying hanging out with each other, whether it was like them falling asleep while watching the TV show or when Hannah was kind of figuring out things with Justin

I didn't read the full series, but I want to know what happens to Justin

That was my only note on the book

I feel like she was obsessed with him in the beginning and then she finally got him to notice her

They're supposed to go on a date and then bam, he's gone

Like she's just like I feel like he deserves a little bit more than that

Like I feel like we need a story line on that

And maybe I am just uneducated and maybe there's a full book on Justin

I hope so

And going back on why I think this is a really good gateway book into romance because it's so light and fluffy, but then there's other parts that aren't so light and fluffy

But I think also right now with like heated rivalry and hockey playing people and I think it's a book that is just really easy to like devour and it definitely is on the lengthier side like what is it? It's like 388 pages to be exact

I also know that Amazon is making it into a TV show

So that was my personal goal is I wanted to read all the books before the TV show came out so that way I could have a little bit of time in between so I could like digest the books and then watch them

I think from the last episode of Booked and Busy, that is something that I learned from Abby is I need to give more time in between the book adaptation books versus movies because when I watch them and read them too close together, I have such high expectations of what's going on in my brain and when they don't align, I get a little let down

And I truly do think when it comes out on Amazon, a lot more people are going to be talking about it

I hope I hope it's produced really well

And I have seen the actors and actresses that are in it

I think it's gonna be pretty good

And I just think with the hockey of it all, it's going to be a lot more spicy

I hope

I will say one thing

If they don't bring Welsie, the nickname, into the TV series, I will be very, very upset

I think a few of my favorite scenes from the book are a lot of the turning point scenes where we go from kind of like a silly game that they're playing to the reality of it

And I think a great example is that views party

I really hope I'm pronouncing that right. when Hannah tells Garrett that she was lying to him about a friend being drugged at a party and it was actually her being drugged at the party and her crying in his arms and I feel like that was a very turning point moment in their relationship and for Hannah to be so openly vulnerable about it

Another one of my favorite scenes is well if you read it you know that they broke up and I hated that

I hated that

If I could change one thing about the book, it would be that I don't think they needed to go so extreme of not speaking to each other

Like, I just hated the dad so much because he was threatening to cut him off from college tuition if he didn't stop seeing Hannah because I think the dad knew that Hannah was good for him

But at the core of all narcissists, you never want anyone around you to be happy

So, obviously, the dad did not want his own son to be happy

So eventually throughout the book, we have a rekindling moment of Garrett and Hannah

I think that was probably my favorite moment

And I just thought it was cute where Garrett was like, "We missed out on this whole month together just because of this stupid, you know, not stupid, but this silly thing." And I think Garrett's dad threatening Hannah to cut off his son's tuition for hockey and Hannah really taking that into consideration and holding herself accountable to not date Garrett anymore was just honestly a little shocking to me because I was like, how are you letting this father who is obviously a control freak control now Hannah's life? And once Garrett obviously finds out what is happening, he rushes over to Hannah's apartment and there's a whole conversation and obviously for a while Garrett is like trying to get back into her life and Hannah's just like nope

And wouldn't tell him why

Yeah

I just think Graham I just think Graham is like the CEO of like a overprotective crazy maybe not so crazy book boyfriend

Now going on a little bit to like the writing style, worldbuing author vibes

I don't feel like the world building was that crazy

This book was more so like a dialogueheavy tensionbuilding book, which I actually preferred for this

And I think if she had a lot of world building, it wouldn't have made sense because like they're in college

If you say the word college, everyone has a picture that comes into their head of what that classroom looks like or what that apartment looks like

I don't think that was super necessary in this book rather than a fantasy book

I feel like you have to have world building or you don't have a book

And then also for the writing style, I definitely think this book is for a younger audience

Like I was saying earlier, it's a little cheesy and sometimes you really need a book like that

And sometimes it's just so freaking unrealistic that that's just never going to happen to you

But it's a feel good read

And I read this during I think it was like April or May, but I haven't read any of the other books in the series

Maybe the writing style shifts

I'm happy that the side characters develop into their own relationships cuz it feels very like Anna Hong to me and I love her

We know this

And that is kind of a wrap- up on this episode, which is The Deal by L

Kennedy

I hope I went deep enough

I know some people, especially on my Patreon, are really requesting like in depth, knees deep conversations, and I don't know how in-depth we're supposed to go and also sometimes talk to myself about this

I feel like I need someone to talk about this with

So, Miss L

Kennedy, I really hope she comes on the episodes times on these things

And happy Valentine's Day

I hope however have you spent it, this can be a little Valentine's Day recap because I think this is going live 2 days after Valentine's Day on the 16th

So whether you're single or in a relationship, I hope this is a little Valentine's Day gift you

I love you guys

Bye. [music] [music] >> [music]